(NEW YORK) — On the heels of the supposed first “functional cure” for HIV in a baby born in Mississippi, French researchers reported Friday that they had studied 14 adult patients who had experienced a similar remission from the virus. The patients in the French study had been off HIV medications for up to 10 years.
The French researchers followed patients who underwent treatment with antiretroviral drugs soon after they’d become infected with HIV. After taking the medications for several years, they stopped taking the antiretrovirals. That was “fashionable at the time,” said Christine Rouzioux, a professor at Necker Hospital and University of Paris Descartes. They are all now in what Rouzioux calls “HIV remission,” because the virus has not worsened and they have not shown symptoms for years.
“I know that the U.S. term is ‘functional cure,'” Rouzioux told ABCNews.com. “In France, we speak about ‘remission.’ … The patient controls the virus, but they still have the virus.”
The study, which was published Friday in the journal PLOS Pathogens, may show that the baby was not the first documented case of someone “functionally cured” of HIV as researchers announced earlier this month.
Rouzioux and Public Library of Science representatives told ABCNews.com that they did not rush their study into publication when the case of the Mississippi baby was announced.
Dr. Deborah Persaud, who works at Johns Hopkins Children’s Center and studied the Mississippi baby, said there were similarities between the 14 French patients and the baby, but that the baby had even lower HIV levels than the French patients.
While Rouzioux and Asier Sáez-Cirión, a senior HIV researcher at the Pasteur Institute in Paris, reported about 100 copies of HIV DNA or RNA per 1 million cells in their patients, Persaud said she found less than five copies of HIV DNA or RNA per 1 million cells in the Mississippi baby.
“I’m not sure anybody knows what that means,” said Dr. Mark Kline, a pediatric HIV and AIDS specialist at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston. “I don’t know that someone with five is necessarily going to be better off in the long term than someone with 100.”
Kline said he, too, has had patients who were technically HIV-positive but have had no need for antiretroviral medication. He has also heard of patients who started antiretroviral therapy and were able to stop without experiencing worsening symptoms.
“This phenomenon that they’re describing has been appreciated and known,” Kline said. “I think there’s a good rationale for saying if you can identify these people and do treatment earlier, you can decrease the viral burden and decrease the reservoirs of infected cells in the body and probably alter the long-term course.”
It can take anywhere from a few weeks to a few years after infection for a person to show symptoms of HIV. As such, early treatment isn’t always an option, according to Kline.
Rouzioux’s patients all experienced symptoms very early, which is why they were able to get swift antiretroviral treatment, she said. Rouzioux and her colleagues followed their patients for about 11 years, she said.
Although these types of patients have been written about before, Kline said this particular study was important because it identified which patients had a genetic predisposition that allowed them to naturally keep HIV at bay and which patients did not, and therefore went into remission because of treatment.
Rouzioux’s colleague, Sáez-Cirión, said about 0.5 percent of all HIV-positive patients were able to control the virus without medication because of a genetic predisposition, but the 14 people in the study did not have this advantage.
The researchers concluded that HIV-positive patients who undergo early treatment for at least one year have a 15 percent chance of going into HIV remission for at least two years after stopping treatment.
“The probability was 10 to 15 percent, which is amazing when compared with the probability of natural (non-drug-induced) control,” Sáez-Cirión said.
Still, it’s not wise for HIV-positive patients to stop taking medications because they can develop resistance to them, Kline said.
“Those are bridges you can burn that you can never rebuild,” he said. “If you just stop treatment or take treatment intermittently, it’s very likely that you’ll develop a resistance to one or more medications. Once a resistance is present in an individual, it’s there to stay. There may be no going back to those particular medications.”
Copyright 2013 ABC News Radio
Natalia Hepworth, EastIdahoNews.com
Debbie Bryce, Idaho State Journal
Sarah Anderson, Deseret News