Lawsuit: Gmail, Yahoo Email Invade Privacy, Even Non-Users' - East Idaho News
Business & Money

Lawsuit: Gmail, Yahoo Email Invade Privacy, Even Non-Users’

  Published at

GETTY B 070212 Inbox?  SQUARESPACE CACHEVERSION=1341227538159iStockphoto/Thinkstock(NEW YORK) — By now most of us have accepted a fact of the digital age: If, say, we write the word “eyeglasses” in the body of an email, advertisements for LensCrafters and Armani specs will most likely pop up on our computer screens soon.  We may not like it, but we understand that we trade privacy for the convenience of modern technology.

But some California residents have decided to take a stand against it, and have filed two class action lawsuits against Google and Yahoo in Marin County Superior Court.  The suits, filed on June 12 and June 28, claim that the web giants illegally intercept emails sent from individual non-Gmail and non-Yahoo subscribers to individual Gmail and Yahoo subscribers, without their knowledge, consent or permission.  What’s more, they say the interception takes place before the email reaches its intended target.

“We began the investigation quite some time ago when a client came to us,” said F. Jerome Tapley, a lawyer in Birmingham, Ala., who represents the plaintiffs.  “They noticed that the ads within their email browser were strangely correlating to the incoming email they were getting from their friends.  It creeps people out.”

In the suit, Stuart Diamond, of Marin County; David Sutton, also of Marin County; and Roland Williams of Sonoma County — none of whom have personal Google or Yahoo email accounts, but have sent emails to people who do — allege that Google and Yahoo are violating the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA), which prohibits anyone from wiretapping or eavesdropping on emails without the consent, knowledge and permission of all parties.

“The invasion of privacy by wiretapping or, in the alternative, eavesdropping, caused by Google and Yahoo’s! continual and pervasive use of such devices seriously threatens the exercise of personal liberties,” the lawyers write.

The suit, which is for unspecified financial damages, was filed on behalf of all residents of California who are not Google or Yahoo email subscribers but have sent emails to people who are. 

Yahoo did not respond to requests for comment, but in an email statement, a Google spokesperson said, “We’re not going to comment on the ongoing litigation.  But to be clear, ad targeting in Gmail is fully automated, and no humans read users’ emails or Google account information in order to show advertisements.”

Copyright 2012 ABC News Radio

SUBMIT A CORRECTION