Shooting Witnesses: Shock Value Could Add to PTSD Vulnerability
(NEW YORK) — A shooting erupted at the midnight premiere showing of Dark Knight Rises in an Aurora, Colo., theater complex filled with young adults, teenagers and young children with their families, some dressed in playful Batman-genre costumes.
Everyone expected a night of fun; not a massacre. Smoke bombs went off. A gunman stalked victims in the aisles, killing at least 12 people. Witnesses said blood was everywhere.
The surprise, as well as the magnitude of the mass shooting, was enough to trigger post-traumatic stress symptoms in those who were vulnerable, said Dr. Jeffrey A. Lieberman, psychiatrist in chief at New York Presbyterian Hospital-Columbia University Medical Center and director of the New York State Psychiatric Institute.
“On the emotional Richter scale it was very high,” he said. “You go to a movie like Batman because it’s fun-loving entertainment, and you are seeing kids in costumes and the last thought you are thinking about is some type of seriously dangerous, potentially life-threatening situation. The contrast adds to the potential for emotional trauma.”
One witness told ABC News, “You just smelled smoke and you just kept hearing it. You just heard bam bam bam, nonstop. “The gunman never had to reload. Shots just kept going, kept going, kept going.”
Psychiatric experts said it was hard to know who would experience serious after-effects of the attack. Only about 7 to 8 percent of all individuals will go on to develop post-traumatic stress disorder, or PTSD, after such an event, according to the Dart Center for Journalism and Trauma.
Most people, if they are not exposed to repeated trauma like war, are resilient and have extraordinary coping skills. But those who are vulnerable can have lifelong effects, said experts.
“We all have our breaking points,” said Lieberman. “Everyone, given sufficient stress, like prisoners of war, have different levels of endurance. But events have a residual effect.”
Nine miles away in 1999, among those who witnessed the slaughter of 19 students and teachers at Columbine High School in Littleton, Colo., a handful went on to experience repeated nightmares, flashbacks and anxiety-related disorders.
“Even for those people who were not affected, these are peripheral events for people who live in the town and in the state, and they can have an identification from the geography and connection to this,” said Lieberman.
About 10 percent of women develop PTSD sometime in their lives compared with 5 percent of men — about 5.2 million adults in a given year, according to the Department of Veterans Affairs.
Children, it seems, are more resilient than adults.
“It has an impact on them,” said Lieberman. “But they have in place readily defined support systems in family and school social structures.”
Those who are most prone to PTSD were directly exposed to a traumatic event — they were either victims or witnesses, or were seriously injured. But one study after the 9/11 attacks found rippling effects on witnesses.
At one school two blocks from the World Trade Center, about 27 percent of staff members who saw a plane fly into one of the towers lost time from work because of physical symptoms, according to a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention study. About one-third reported symptoms consistent with depression.
The degree to which people are affected is determined by their proximity and how sustained or horrific their exposure; their own psychological make-up and the help they receive after the event.
“Your individual vulnerability and resilience is determined by your genetic make-up, and also in part by the psychological features you have developed over the course of your lifetime — were you confident and successful and could you overcome experiences, or were you cautious and fearful?” said Lieberman.
The best approach for immediate support is a technique called psychological first aid, according to Robin Kerner, director of quality initiative and outcomes at St. Luke’s-Roosevelt Hospital Center in New York City.
Rather than asking people to retell their traumatic stories, responders tend to the victims’ immediate needs, reassure and comfort them and “perhaps, most importantly, connect them with their social supports.
“Research has shown that the retelling of the traumatic story in the immediate aftermath can lead to retraumatization and does not provide comfort to victims,” said Kerner.
The probability of developing PTSD is increased if the victims had direct exposure or were seriously hurt or believed they or their families were in danger. Reactions such as crying, shaking, vomiting, feeling apart from their surroundings or helpless to get out, can be signals, Kerner said.
An earlier life-threatening event, a history of child abuse or mental problems raises the vulnerability level.
Those exposed to the movie theater shooting through images and reports on Twitter may see these posts and feel anxious or worried.
Viewing such events can be “disturbing if not dangerous” for young children, said Dr. Eugene Beresin, director of training in child and adolescent psychiatry at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston.
“This has largely been seen and studied in a number of situations, such as the Oklahoma City Bombing, the Challenger disaster and the 9/11 attack,” he said. “There is considerable evidence that PTSD in kids may develop by watching such events in the media.”
Parents can help their children by encouraging them to express their thoughts about the event, and reassure them they are safe. Stick to usual routines, and seek help if the child has distressing dreams of the event or relives the trauma through repetitive play.
Experts recommend that parents limit their children’s viewing of television news coverage of the Aurora shooting. Pediatric research shows it can be associated with more long-term distress.
No one is exempt from that emotional distress, say experts.
“One reason is that events such as this are a threat to our assumptive world,” said Dr. David J. Schonfeld, director of the National Center for School Crisis and Bereavement at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center.
“Every day, we make assumptions about our safety and those we care about. Otherwise, we may become overwhelmed by the harsh reality that, at any point, tragedy can happen to those we love,” he said. “When something like this event occurs, it forces us to acknowledge that these are assumptions and therefore may not be true. It leaves us feeling vulnerable and unsettled.”
Copyright 2012 ABC News Radio