Boise football players sue to challenge punishments over Snapchat messages
Published at
BOISE (Idaho Statesman) — Four Timberline High School students involved in a Snapchat discussion that the school board called “vulgar and violent” have sued Boise school officials in federal court, saying they were subjected to unfair disciplinary processes.
The lawsuit also provided details of the students’ punishments. All four were removed from the school for extended periods, the filing says, though at least two briefly returned to Timberline before being pulled out of class less than 40 minutes later.
The teens’ disciplinary process began after photos were shared on the social media platform Snapchat that showed messages suggesting they could rape or kill a female student. The four Timberline football players allegedly sent the messages in a group chat titled “Gameday lunch.” The photos were widely circulated online in the Boise community, and a petition calling for disciplinary action garnered nearly 16,000 views. Timberline students held a walkout on Oct. 7 to support the targeted student and call for disciplinary action.
The lawsuit includes quotes from the Snapchat conversation, including:
- “U think Cornell was bad just wait for US,” which referred to a notorious case in which a female Cornell student alleged seven male students sexually assaulted her.
- “Let’s hang her from a high post and let the birds pick at her brains for days.”
- ”Let’s make her life hell.”
- “The conversation for if she deserves to die is there.”
The lawsuit does not dispute that the students wrote the messages.
The students — referred to as John Does in the lawsuit — were initially given a two-day disciplinary suspension, then an additional five-day suspension, followed by a 10-day suspension, according to the court filing. Ultimately, the district ordered three students into Boise Online School — two for the rest of the fall semester, one through graduation in May — while the fourth accepted temporary home instruction with no return date set.
The lawsuit alleged the district imposed those 17 days of suspension without giving the students a “meaningful” chance to respond. It also asserts that hearings were held on short notice after senior officials had already publicly condemned the messages and promised accountability, suggesting they already had decided the students were guilty before the process began.
The lawsuit named Boise School District Superintendent Wendy Johnson, Deputy Superintendent Nick Smith, Timberline Principal Chad Wright, Timberline Area Director Shelley Bonds and Borah Area Director Jason Hutchison. It was filed Nov. 6 in Idaho’s U.S. District Court by three 18-year-old students and one unnamed parent of an underage student.
Bonds and Johnson did not respond to the Idaho Statesman’s request for comment. Wright, Smith and Hutchison forwarded the Statesman’s request to Boise School District spokesman Dan Hollar, who said they would not comment on ongoing litigation.
While the Boise School District was not among those sued, Hollar said the district “has no comment on the allegations or on whether the District will be involved on behalf of the named defendants.”
Lawsuit alleges messages’ context was left out
The Snapchat messages sent Sept. 30 stemmed from some Timberline football players spotting another player, referenced in the lawsuit by the pseudonym James Poe, with a girl, referred to as Jane Moe, whom he had “been dating on and off for months.”
“The teammates were extremely concerned for James Poe because Jane Moe had been harassing him,” the lawsuit stated.
At about 10 p.m. that night, the players began messaging each other and sent the aggressive statements.
The lawsuit alleges that these messages were not a “serious expression of an intent to commit violence,” but instead “merely a criticism of their friend’s relationship with the female student.”
“None of the messages related to sexual assault,” the complaint said. “(A plaintiff) alleges that his sexually derogatory remarks were intended as crude commentary … . Plaintiffs do not deny that their private language with their friend was distasteful.”
The lawsuit did not address the messages related to her death.
Students say their side was not heard
In the court filing, the students suggested school officials already had decided to discipline them before listening to their side of the story.
“As I’m sure all are aware, some of our players made disgraceful comments about another student,” Ian Smart, Timberline’s football coach, wrote in a message to the team on Oct. 3, according to the lawsuit. “At this time, I am working with our school administration to determine what the consequences for these students’ actions will be moving forward.”
The lawsuit pointed to public statements made by officials one day after the messages went public.
On Oct. 4, Wright, Bonds and Johnson issued a statement that described “disturbing social media posts” and said “there is zero tolerance for the type of behavior and language attributed to any member of our school community.”
The lawsuit alleges the students “had not yet even been questioned by the school, investigated, or in any way been determined guilty of any accusations.”
That same day, Timberline’s principal and an assistant principal called each of the four students’ parents to notify them that the students were to stay home for two days for “the safety of all involved,” the lawsuit said.
The school eventually gave the students the 15 additional days of suspension. Two students attempted to return to school after that penalty elapsed, but an assistant principal removed them from class 36 minutes later, the lawsuit said.
An attorney for one of those boys contacted the school and was told that a decision had been made to assign his client and another of the students to Boise Online School. “The written decision will be sent shortly,” the attorney was told.
Disciplinary process was messy, lawsuit says
The lawsuit noted a number of instances in which the school appeared to handle the investigation and discipline in a rushed, sloppy manner.
The students allege they were told about their hearings on short notice, which did not allow them enough time to prepare.
Other examples in the complaint included incorrect dates and names on documents, sending a notice by email instead of the hand or mail delivery required by school policy, omitting the time and dates of a hearing in a notification and mistakenly counting a disciplined student as absent.
Through the lawsuit, the students are seeking a declaration that officials denied them due process, an end to any disciplinary actions imposed without adequate process, an agreement allowing the students to return to school, and removal of related adverse disciplinary records. It also seeks monetary compensation, coverage of attorney fees and costs and any other relief the court deems appropriate.
Boise Police are conducting a separate criminal investigation into the messages. Boise Police spokesperson Haley Kramer told the Statesman on Monday that the department has reviewed the available evidence and is waiting on additional evidence from social media platforms.
“It is anticipated that it will take time to receive and evaluate this additional evidence and interview additional witnesses based on that new information,” Kramer said.
No criminal charges had been filed as of Monday.


