Most recipients of Idaho's private education tax credit never attended public school - East Idaho News
Submit a name to Secret Santa
Education

Most recipients of Idaho’s private education tax credit never attended public school

  Published at
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready ...

BOISE(Idaho Ed News) — Idaho’s private education tax credit is primarily subsidizing tuition for wealthy families whose children were already enrolled in a private school, according to a report released Friday.

The Idaho State Tax Commission, for the first time, released a wide range of data that sheds light on the beneficiaries of the $50 million, taxpayer-funded Parental Choice Tax Credit program. GOP members of the Legislature and Republican Gov. Brad Little created the state’s first private school choice program last year through House Bill 93.

Here are some of the highlights from the report:

  • 12,216 students received a tax credit or advance payment.
  • 80.7% attend a private school and 19.3% are home schooling.
  • 74.7% have never attended a public school.
  • $178,000 is the average adjusted gross income for recipient households.
  • 1.7 is the average number of students per household that received a credit.
  • 55.5% of households earn more and 44.5% earn less than 300% of the federal poverty level, a benchmark determining who had the first dibs on the credits.
  • 93.5% of tax credits covered tuition expenses.

In other words, the typical credit covered private school tuition for a family of four that earns $178,000 and whose children never attended a public school. Idaho’s median household income is $84,234, according to U.S. Census data.

Friday’s report undermines a key selling point of the bitterly debated private school choice program: that it would help students who couldn’t otherwise afford private education options.

“Idahoans were sold a lie about this voucher scheme,” House Minority Leader Ilana Rubel, D-Boise, said in a news release Friday. “We were told this program would help low-income children leave public schools for supposedly better-performing private schools. Instead, more than half of the families awarded tax credits are above the income threshold Republicans promised to prioritize, and nearly three-quarters of students have never attended an Idaho public school.”

The refundable tax credit offers Idaho students, regardless of their family’s income, up to $5,000 — or $7,500 if they have special needs — to reimburse their non-public education costs, including tuition, curriculum and tutoring, among other things.

Idaho Education News and others had sought data on the program’s rollout for months, but the Tax Commission denied records requests, promising a report by January. The agency ultimately published the report earlier than expected but 10 days after the Nov. 3 election, when all 105 state lawmakers and the governor were up for re-election.

“Voters deserved this information before casting their ballots,” Rubel said. “We should repeal this program or, at the very least, end subsidies for higher-income families.”

However, the report includes more data than HB 93 required. A provision in the bill told the Tax Commission to compile a report on the program’s first year with several data points. But it didn’t call for the percentage of students who previously attended a public school.

In a statement Friday, Little said his administration “went above and beyond to provide as much information and data as possible while protecting taxpayers’ personal information.”

“This report gives policymakers and the public a clearer picture of the program and provides the best available data to evaluate its effectiveness, identify opportunities for improvement, and ensure it continues to serve Idahoans well,” Little said in a news release.

Emily Callihan, Little’s communications director, declined EdNews’ request to interview the governor Friday.

EdNews also reached out to tax commissioner Janet Moyle along with Senate Majority Leader Lori Den Hartog and House Majority Leader Jason Monks. The Republican lawmakers from Meridian co-sponsored HB 93 along with former Rep. Wendy Horman, a Republican from Idaho Falls, who now works for the Trump administration.

The Tax Commission’s report includes a list of private schools where the state is reimbursing tuition. This data also wasn’t required by HB 93.

Here were the top five beneficiary schools:

  • Cole Valley Christian School — 642 awards — $3.1 million.
  • The Ambrose School — 572 awards — $2.7 million.
  • Bishop Kelly High School — 406 awards — $1.9 million.
  • Nampa Christian Schools — 373 awards — $1.7 million.
  • Logos Classical Christian School — 343 awards — $1.5 million.

Click here to read the report.

Idaho’s public school teachers’ union, which unsuccessfully sued to block the tax credit program last year, released a statement Friday calling it a “failed experiment.” The Idaho Education Association (IEA) also noted that nearly two-thirds of awards went to students in three urban counties.

Just under 66% of applications came from Ada (Boise/Meridian), Canyon (Nampa/Caldwell) and Kootenai (Coeur d’Alene/Post Falls) counties, according to the Tax Commission’s report.

“Just like in every other state that has adopted them, vouchers in Idaho have proven to be a subsidy for wealthy families in urban areas who want all Idahoans to pay for their children’s elitist education or their family’s religious beliefs,” IEA President Peggy Hoy said in a news release.

IEA, along with several other plaintiffs, last year filed a lawsuit asking the Idaho Supreme Court to declare the Parental Choice Tax Credit program unconstitutional. The Supreme Court unanimously upheld the program in February.

Idaho’s private school choice program is following a familiar trend. As Republican-led states across the U.S. unlocked taxpayer funds for private schoolers in recent years, most of the money has gone to students who were already attending a private school or learning at home.

SUBMIT A CORRECTION