‘They buried him in a duffel bag.’ Idaho police detail pursuit of missing 5-year-old
Published at | Updated at
FRUITLAND (Idaho Statesman) — Michael Vaughan was 5 years old when he disappeared while playing outside in his Fruitland neighborhood in the summer of 2021.
Since then, law enforcement has appeared to circle around four possible suspects: Stacey Wondra, his then-wife Sarah Wondra and their two former roommates.
Detectives had their eyes on them almost immediately. But there wasn’t enough evidence to move forward with charges related to Michael’s abduction for years. Prosecutors tried in November 2022 charging Sarah with failure to report Michael’s death, but dropped the charge about five months later.
Then four years into the case, Stacey was charged on Oct. 30, 2025, with first-degree murder, second-degree kidnapping and destruction of evidence in connection with Michael’s disappearance.
RELATED | Suspect in Idaho boy’s disappearance to stand trial on murder, other charges
RELATED | Michael Vaughan case: Sarah Wondra booked into Payette County Jail on murder charge
Sarah was arrested last week — on Nov. 10 — on the same charges and booked into the Payette County Jail on a $1 million bond.
Michael still hasn’t been found.
A probable cause affidavit written by Fruitland Police Detective Juanita Kelleher was recently made public and provided an updated look at the evidence collected by law enforcement in the case.
The Idaho Statesman compiled a timeline of evidence in the Vaughan case using Kelleher’s affidavit. All information below comes from that document unless otherwise noted.
Timeline of events
July 27, 2021: Michael disappears
6:08-6:28 p.m. — Surveillance captured a man, later identified as Wondra roommate B, walking through the neighborhood. When later questioned by police, roommate B said he had been searching for a missing child. Police noted that roommate B left for his walk before Michael went missing.
About 6:15-6:30 p.m. — Neighbors reported seeing Michael near his home and nearby residences. Michael knocked on some of his neighbors’ doors, “attempting to play with neighbors or in their yards,” the affidavit said. The neighbors all said they told Michael to return home.
6:25-7:25 p.m. — A Fruitland resident reported seeing Michael riding a tricycle near the Wondra residence, a few streets from the Vaughan home. She could not remember if it was as she was arriving at 6:25 p.m. or leaving at 7:25 p.m.
Approximately 6:45-6:50 p.m. — Tyler Vaughan noticed his son was missing and began to search.
7:08 p.m. — Surveillance video and cellphone records indicate Sarah drove her maroon GMC to Kuna. Stacey and roommate B were also in the car.
7:21 p.m. — Tyler Vaughan called 911 to report his son missing.

11:22 p.m. — Surveillance showed the GMC returning to the neighborhood towing a silver Mercedes-Benz.
August-December 2021
Aug. 1 — Fruitland police contacted residents at the Wondra home. Roommate A was found hiding in a closet. Sarah, Stacey and the two roommates were interviewed.
Aug. 2–3 — Live-scent K-9 teams searched about 300 homes in the area. The only places a dog showed interest were the Wondras’ home, the corner of Meadowlark and Redwing Street and bushes near a bluff close to the Wondras’ home.
Aug. 8 — Sarah messaged Stacey that she wanted to move. Sarah said she wanted to “get out of this neighborhood and this house.”
Aug. 12 — Phone communication showed a falling-out between Stacey and roommate B. Roommate B was kicked out of the house. Sarah changed her phone number.
August-December — The affidavit stated that Sarah began showing a “distinct change in behavior” after Michael’s disappearance.
She began standing along the highway near Love’s Gas Station in Ontario, Oregon, “with signs stating to repent your sins and that the end of time was near,” the affidavit said.
Sarah also began to post on social media significantly more.
Between January 2021 and July 2021, Sarah made three Facebook posts. From August 2021 to December 2021, Sarah made 343 Facebook posts.
In the three years prior, Sarah had made 11 TikTok videos. From Sept. 14, 2021, to Dec. 24, 2021, she made 329 TikTok videos.
The posts were “very religious and spoke about repentance and forgiveness,” the affidavit said.
In TikTok videos Sarah posted, she made statements regarding her involvement in criminal behaviors and stated that she had broken all of the Ten Commandments.
“It should be noted that ‘thou shalt not kill’ is one of the Ten Commandments,” the affidavit said. “Sarah also alleged in her videos that it did not matter what sins she had committed because God had forgiven her for all of them.”

Nov. 15, 2021 — Police again interviewed Sarah and Stacey. The affidavit says Sarah changed her account of the trip to Kuna after being shown surveillance footage, though it did not describe her first account.
When asked, Sarah said the reasons she and Stacey changed phones after Michael’s abduction were because the Wondras were splitting up and because a demon told her to sell her phone.
“I literally had like a demon tell me that I need to leave my husband,” Sarah told law enforcement.
Sarah also told them that her GMC pickup truck was repossessed. Law enforcement later learned that “the truck appeared to have been thoroughly cleaned before the repo,” the affidavit said.
After the interview, the Wondras contacted roommate B. They suggested he create an alibi or write a letter on their behalf saying that they were not involved in Michael’s abduction, according to the affidavit.

2022-2023
April 14, 2022 — Sarah was arraigned on charges unrelated to Michael, including aggravated assault with a deadly weapon, unlawful possession of a firearm, destruction of evidence, battery and possession of a controlled substance, according to court records.
May 17, 2022 — Sarah’s unrelated charges were dismissed at the prosecution’s request, and a judge ordered her released, according to court records.
June 2022 — Sarah spoke to her mother on a recorded jail line about whether spouses could testify against one another. In another call, Stacey told Sarah he was worried she would “turn on” him. Sarah confirmed that he was talking about Michael before assuring him she wouldn’t testify against him. It is unclear from records why she was calling from jail.
October 12, 2022 — Law enforcement met again with Sarah. Sarah said God told her he was going to help her find Michael. She wrote a “testimony,” and said that if law enforcement read it, they would locate him, the affidavit said.
“Sarah suggested God had forgiven Hitler for his sins, that God had redeemed Sarah for her sins,” the affidavit says.
Around this time, Sarah began standing in her driveway and urinating, causing neighbors to request welfare checks.
Nov. 5, 2022 — Shortly before 1 a.m., Stacey requested an interview from the Washington County Jail. He was being held there in an unrelated federal case related to illegal gun possession, according to federal court records. Stacey had been out on bail for this case at the time of Michael’s disappearance. It is unclear from police records when he returned to jail.
He provided vague details, saying within two days of Michael’s disappearance, Sarah’s behavior changed, and she began acting more religious. He also mentioned switching phones or SIM cards so law enforcement couldn’t track him.

Nov. 10, 2022 — Stacey asked to speak with Fruitland detectives, saying he was ready to confess. Stacey told police that Michael had been in his house the night he disappeared and described first seeing the child when Sarah carried him into their home.
Michael was taped up, placed in a duffel bag while still alive and put in the bed of the Wondras’ pickup truck, according to Stacey. While describing this part to detectives, Stacey “had a physical reaction and began violently vomiting,” the affidavit stated.
Stacey told police that Sarah and the two roommates drove Michael to the Kuna home of roommate B’s mother, who was out of town, according to a memorandum filed by Stacey’s attorney in his federal case.
Stacey said the three returned the next day to find Michael dead, causing them to return home and bury him in the Wondras’ backyard, the memorandum stated.
After the interview, Stacey called his mom on a recorded line to tell her that Sarah had accidentally killed Michael.
“How?” Stacey’s mother asked.
“Suffocation,” he responded. “… They buried him in a duffel bag.”
After the phone call, Stacey wrote an apology letter to Michael’s parents and attempted to hang himself in his jail cell, according to the affidavit. Police said Washington County Jail staff rescued him.
Nov. 12, 2022 — Police executed a search warrant on the Wondra home and arrested Sarah on a felony charge for failure to report Michael’s death.
The affidavit noted that Sarah made several strange statements about Michael’s death, including, “The most high God just told me that Stacey was the one who did it” and “Stacey was the one that killed him and he buried him.”
Five cadaver K-9s alerted in the Wondras’ backyard, but no human remains were found. Law enforcement noted several areas in the yard appeared to have been filled in with dirt or re-sodded. Sarah’s parents said they had filled in holes dug by the Wondras’ dog.

March 29, 2023 — Sarah was arraigned again on charges from April 2022 unrelated to Michael’s case. These include aggravated assault and destruction of evidence.
July 2023 — A woman, whose relation to Sarah was not reported in the affidavit, informed police that Sarah had told her in 2022 that Stacey was involved in abducting a 5-year-old boy. In a recorded jail call, Sarah later told the woman that she’d misunderstood that statement. On the same call, the woman mentioned that Sarah’s dog was digging large holes in the backyard.
Oct. 6, 2023 — Sarah was sentenced to three years in prison.
Oct. 13, 2023 — Detectives and the Cold Case Foundation interviewed Sarah again. The affidavit said Sarah “had a strong emotional response and began to cry” when Michael was mentioned.
“God told me he was going to help me find the boy.” Sarah told them, “God forgives everybody.”
Sarah later “complained about people saying she did something bad.” The jailer asked her what was going on. She replied, “I don’t know if it was him. I don’t know what body I saw. … I don’t know it was in a bag. I couldn’t see it.”
Nov. 1, 2023 — A federal judge sentenced Stacey to 21 months for illegal firearm possession, followed by a period of supervised release.
Jan. 27, 2025 — Stacey filed for divorce from Sarah. Stacey had previously filed for divorce in November 2023, but a judge dismissed it after Stacey let the case become inactive.
March 26, 2025 — A federal judge revoked the possibility of supervised release in Stacey’s firearm possession case on the grounds that he violated probation agreements.
He was ordered to remain in prison for another year.
Oct. 31, 2025 — Idaho law enforcement charged Stacey with first-degree murder, second-degree kidnapping and destruction of evidence in connection with Michael’s case.
Feb. 19, 2026 — The Wondras’ divorce was finalized.
Nov. 10, 2026 — Sarah was arrested on first-degree murder, second-degree kidnapping and destruction of evidence in connection with Michael’s case. Payette County Sheriff Andrew Creech told the Statesman she was arrested right after her release from prison.


