IFG commissioner urges nonprofit to drop payments for killing newborn wolf pups
Published at
An Idaho Fish and Game commissioner asked the director of a nonprofit organization that pays hunters and trappers who kill wolves to ban the payments for animals taken during the wolf denning season.
The commission and the Idaho Department of Fish and Game have a memorandum of understanding with the Foundation For Wildlife Management and grant the organization about $200,000 annually to help fund its program that reimburses wolf trappers and hunters for the expenses they incur.
All three entities are under scrutiny following a news article that showed the foundation paid trappers up to $2,000 for each of 12 newborn wolf pups that were killed after being pulled from their dens earlier this year.
The foundation, also known as F4WM reimburses trappers and hunters up to $2,500 for wolves taken in areas where livestock attacks are common and up to $2,000 in areas where elk are struggling. Many wildlife advocates compare the reimbursement payments to bounties.
The Idaho Department of Fish and Game and its governing commission that met in Lewiston Wednesday have been enthusiastic backers of the program and have viewed it as an important strategy in their effort to scale back the state’s wolf population, last estimated at about 11,000 animals. The state has a population goal of about 650 wolves and allows long and liberal wolf hunting and trapping seasons.
Killing newborn wolf pups is legal under a 2021 state law but pushes the bounds of social acceptance and has garnered strong reactions on social media from across the country and around the world and from hunters and anglers in the Gem State. Idaho Fish and Game Director Jim Fredericks called it “distasteful” and noted when the agency renewed its contract with the foundation earlier this year, it stipulated that state money can’t be used for reimbursements for wolves killed in May and June, the heart of wolf denning season.
Commissioner Tim Murphy of Boise asked Justin Webb, director of the foundation, to do the same.
“I’d sure like to see you and your board align with Fish and Game so those funds are put aside and not applied for reimbursement in (May and June),” said Murphy. “I think that would be a great alignment as neighbors across Idaho.”
Webb told the Lewiston Tribune during a break in the meeting that the foundation’s board is in the process of considering how it might respond to the controversial practice.
“The F4WM board is sympathetic to that. We’ve been in indepth discussions but at this time I don’t have authority from the board to even make a statement,” he said. “There’s been in depth discussions for the last 30 days on the situation, how it came to be and what we can do going forward.”
On Tuesday, a coalition of conservation organizations led by the International Wildlife Coexistence Network submitted a petition asking the Fish and Game Commission to adopt rules that protect wolf pups and their mothers until at least Sept. 1, forbid the taking of wolves at denning sites, and to close wolf season by proclamation from April 1 through July 31 until the new rules take effect.
The commission won’t consider the petition until its next meeting in January but Fredericks said the state law passed in 2021 largely usurped the commission’s authority to regulate wolf harvest. It eliminated limits on the number of wolves individual hunters and trappers can take, wiped away restrictions on the methods they can use and instituted nearly year-round seasons on private land.
“Much, if not all, of what the petitioners are asking for is outside the purview of the commission,” Fredericks said.
Dallas Gudgel of the International Wildlife Coexistence Network said even with the state law, the commission and department could expand the ban on what he called wolf bounties well beyond May and June and likely has more flexibility on wolf hunting and trapping rules than they admit.
“I’d like to see (the payment ban during the denning season) go to September 1, so I think there’s more things they could do,” he said. “We will work with them. We can talk about rulemaking and see what kind of language we can use and see if we can make it enforceable. I think they can move seasons as well and I believe that wouldn’t go outside of what they think their restrictions are based on Idaho code.”


