A man’s body disposed of in 6 trash bags. Now his wife and daughter are being charged
Published atSACRAMENTO (KXTV) — A newly filed felony complaint provides more details about what prosecutors allege happened after a Citrus Heights man was killed and his remains were found in the Foresthill area in 2022.
Prosecutors allege Mary Elizabeth Fitzmaurice killed her father, Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice, between Sept. 16 and Sept. 28, 2022. They also accuse her of working with her mother, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, to dismember his body and dispose of the remains. The allegations are outlined in a felony complaint filed in Placer County Superior Court.
“Mary, the daughter, is charged with the murder of Paul Fitzmaurice. She’s also charged with an enhancement for using a weapon. They are both charged with conspiracy to obstruct justice for the lies that they told about Paul still being alive over the past several years,” Placer County District Attorney Morgan Gire said.
According to the complaint filed Thursday, the women allegedly placed Paul’s head, torso, arms and legs into six separate garbage bags in Citrus Heights before loading them into Mary’s vehicle.
“I will just say sort of generally, we recovered the head of Mr. Fitzmaurice, and injuries sustained to that head can lead us to believe the manner in which he died,” Gire said.
The two allegedly drove toward Foresthill, where they stopped at multiple locations in the forest to leave the bags. The complaint specifically alleges they carried the torso into the forest and separately left Paul’s head in Foresthill.
“I will confirm the rest of Paul’s body has never been located, so based on the information, including witness statements and physical evidence, we believe the remaining parts of Paul’s body were scattered in various locations,” Gire said.
Prosecutors also allege the women concealed his death from friends and family, repeatedly claiming he was still alive. Mary allegedly told an investigator posing as a Citrus Heights police officer that her father was alive during a Nov. 11 interview in Roseville. Both women allegedly made similar claims to Placer County sheriff’s deputies on Nov. 17.
The filing also outlines an alleged financial motive for concealing his death. Prosecutors say Gwenn continued collecting Paul’s CalPERS pension and Social Security payments through November 2026 without reporting his death to either agency.
Gwenn faces two felony grand theft charges related to the payments, along with charges of being an accessory after the fact, and conspiracy to obstruct justice.
Mary faces both murder and conspiracy charges. Prosecutors also allege she used a deadly weapon in the killing.
“This (case) is disturbing by its very nature and its facts. But the level of proof in our confidence level remains the same as in any criminal case,” Gire said.
Both women were arrested Nov. 17 and remain in custody without bail at the South Placer Jail, according to the Placer County Sheriff’s Office.
The two women did not enter a plea. Their next court hearing is set for Dec. 4, where Gire says there may be an argument about their bail and custody status.
This story first appeared on fellow CNN affiliate KXTV. It is used with permission.

