Washington apples used to be a local industry. Then a state agency decided to finance a corporate takeover of orchards - East Idaho News
Submit a name to Secret Santa
Agriculture

Washington apples used to be a local industry. Then a state agency decided to finance a corporate takeover of orchards

  Published at
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready ...

CHELAN, Wash. (The Spokesman-Review) — International Farming Corp. hit the motherlode when it struck up a close relationship with the Washington State Investment Board 10 years ago.

The Raleigh, North Carolina, investment firm specializing in agriculture left Olympia with its coffers bulging with more than a half-billion dollars.

And the apple industry, the crown jewel of Washington agriculture, has never been the same.

International Farming used the $537.5 million it received from the state’s investment board as a springboard for its unprecedented and controversial incursion into the $2 billion-a-year industry. The investment board is a state agency that manages money for Washington’s public pension fund and other programs.

Using some of that money, IFC is just days away from closing its largest acquisition to date. If it succeeds in buying the Gebbers Farms assets out of bankruptcy court, IFC will become the largest apple company in Washington and the entire country.

Today, competing growers, former insiders and state agriculture leaders are raising questions about IFC and some of the moves it has made in its 10-year push into Washington . Some question its business acumen, others its integrity.

Still others are furious that the state investment board would help finance IFC’s dramatic expansion, essentially assisting an out-of-state investment manager compete with outgunned local farmers.

“The reported involvement of the State Investment Board in providing financial support to International Farming Corporation is troubling,” said Derek Sandison, director of the Washington Department of Agriculture.

“Such support raises legitimate concerns about whether remaining Washington apple producers are being placed at a competitive disadvantage, particularly as many family-owned operations continue to face significant financial pressures,” he said.

Others are more blunt.

“I can see why local growers are upset,” said Desmond O’Rourke, a retired agriculture economist in Pullman. “The board is in essence financing their major competitor.”

IFC vows that its aggressive move into Washington will be good for the state and farming.

“This has been an incredibly challenging period for Washington’s tree fruit industry, and we recognize the uncertainty and pressures facing growers, farmworkers, and communities across the state,” said Charlie McNairy, CEO of International Farming. “At a time when access to funding across the industry is increasingly limited, we are deepening our commitment to Washington agriculture because we believe in the people who make this industry possible. We are grateful to be in a position to support local growers, preserve jobs, and contribute to a stronger future for Washington’s tree fruit industry.”

As for the investment board, it defends its oversight of its money managers.

“The WSIB takes its fiduciary responsibilities to beneficiaries seriously. We conduct extensive up-front and ongoing due diligence on every investment we make. We have long invested in the agricultural sector as we believe it offers attractive returns over time,” the board wrote in a statement responding to questions. “Our agricultural holdings are global in scope, including investments in Washington state. We expect all our agricultural fund managers to establish and maintain constructive working relationships within their local farming communities.”

McNairy and his team of senior executives traveled to Olympia in 2014 to spread the good news: He and his team had cracked the code on how to make money in agriculture.

Typically, IFC purchases a farm and then hires the original owner as a tenant farmer. IFC then sends agronomists, soil scientists and a shock troop of proven talents from other farms to quickly transform newly acquired properties. As yields increase, so do profits, McNairy said.

Washington board members and staffers liked what they heard. “This is the big leagues of agriculture,” said John Graves, an in-house analyst.

In the ensuing four years, the board committed $537 million to three different investment vehicles.

It was great news for IFC. It was suddenly flush with new investment capital. Plus, the investment board would pay IFC annual management fees.

The investment industry’s entry into the apple business has already been good news for apple farmers who sold out, said Jill McCluskey, director of the school of economic sciences at Washington State University.

Apples have become a very hard business in recent years due to unrelenting increases in expenses and flat demand. Under that scenario, a well-capitalized company with an appetite for expansion should be welcomed, McCluskey said.

The Washington State Investment Board does not disclose the compensation paid to any of its investment managers, said James Aber, a spokesman for the fund.

Typically, the management fee would be between 1% and 2% per year of total committed capital, said Eric Rosenfeld, CEO of the Oregon Venture Fund, an early-stage venture fund in Portland. Plus, there are other fees.

“The industry is notorious for being very creative in figuring their fees,” Rosenfeld said. “You and I will never know who’s paying what to whom.”

Since then, IFC has acquired at least five companies, thousands of acres of orchards, multiple packing sheds and interests in multiple sales operations.

In the private equity business, it’s known as a corporate rollup. These mergers aim to achieve economies of scale, reduce competition and create a company with greater market power.

“Consolidation is their watchword,” said Brendan Ballou, a former U.S. Department of Justice attorney who wrote a book about private equity. “That gives them control.”

In 2019, IFC acquired Legacy Fruit in Wapato. The transaction included 4,000 acres of orchard as well as two packing warehouses.

Dean Gardner, CEO of Legacy, got an offer to stay with IFC. He did, looking forward to learning more about how this company operated. He quickly became disillusioned.

The super-competent farmers coming in to assist never materialized.

“There was no one on staff who could come close to matching Legacy’s experienced farm managers,” Gardner said.

One of IFC’s outside experts shocked the locals when it became clear that he didn’t know what a bin was. The square boxes that pickers empty their apple bags into are ubiquitous in orchard country.

It was a common complaint even by those who were supportive of IFC.

“I think that they realized after the acquisitions that they had a very steep learning curve,” said Ed Johnson, former CEO of Chelan Fruit. “But I don’t think there’s anything evil about IFC. I think they are progressive minded. And they were very grower friendly.”

In 2021, IFC turned its eyes to the north. It bought two owners’ cooperatives in the Chelan Valley. Observers were bewildered. Chelan Fruit was financially struggling and losing members. Manson Growers was better managed. But it was tiny.

It was at Chelan Fruit that IFC ran into the powerful Gebbers family, which for six generations had run one of the largest orchard operations in the state.

The Gebbers were members of the cooperative and by far the largest contributor of apples to the cooperative’s packing warehouse. If anybody was going to take control of Chelan Fruit, Gebbers felt it should be them.

It came down to a vote of the membership. IFC carried the day, in part because management endorsed them.

A group of dissident Chelan Fruit owners sued the cooperative claiming that IFC had failed to pay growers the full, promised purchase price.

The Gebbers operation also sued IFC claiming the vote was rigged and that IFC won after “engaging in a campaign of misinformation.”

The one lasting impact was intense bad blood between IFC and the Gebbers.

The controversial election and disputed payments to Chelan Fruit’s grower members got back to the Washington State Investment Board.

In 2023, Alma Torres-Jones, a grower based in Omak, went to the board with her complaints.

“I have come to understand that you are an investor into IFC and am asking for your assistance to get answers,” Torres-Jones said in a May 2023 email to fund officials. “We former cooperative farmers/growers believed what we were told, only to find out that we have been rolled over by this multibillion-dollar firm.”

Whether the investment board attempted to intervene is unclear. Neither investment board officials nor Torres-Jones would comment.

Documents provided by the investment board in response to public records requests indicate that the board referred Torres-Jones to Chelan Fruit and IFC executives.

Today there are signs that IFC is suffering from the apple industry slump just as its competitors.

IFC subsidiaries have filed plans with the Chelan County Planning Department to build a large residential subdivision on orchard land it owns in Manson.

It is also negotiating to sell senior water rights directly from Lake Chelan. Officials at the Chelan PUD confirmed that they are negotiating with IFC to buy the rights.

In addition, IFC is trying to sell water rights from the Snake River near the Tri-Cities.

“Occasionally, there are instances where land can no longer be sustainably farmed,” IFC said in a written statement. “In those cases, responsible stewardship means considering other options for that land. Those situations are the exception. Our primary focus remains investing in farms, agricultural businesses and the communities around them for the long term.”

Sandison, head of the state agriculture department who criticized the state investment board for backing IFC, added, “While we generally want to see our farms remain locally and family owned, the North Carolina firms appear to have been operating within the bounds of the free market.”

Not everyone agrees.

Art Jarvis, a longtime real estate investor, thought he had hit it big in 2021 when three companies affiliated with IFC leased hundreds of acres of apple orchards owned by Jarvis companies.

Early this year, less than halfway through the lease term, IFC stopped paying, Jarvis claimed. He got a letter from Steve Clement, IFC’s point man in the Northwest, saying the company “could no longer perform” under the leases. “The realities of the market have proven overwhelming,” the letter reads.

“I’m furious that a company can sign a 10-year lease and default with six years remaining,” Jarvis said. “By placing the leases in LLC entities with no money or assets, they are trying to avoid all responsibility, even though they are a subsidiary of a multibillion-dollar multinational farming operation.”

Jarvis sued IFC in June in U.S. District Court in Richland.

“I think it’s important that people know how this company operates,” Jarvis added.

Another lawsuit came late last week. But this was not from a rival grower or a landlord. The plaintiff is Manson Growers Holdings, a member of the IFC family. Manson Growers ran a cooperative that stores, processes and sells apples for its approximately 100 members. The lead defendant is Chelan Fruit, the rival cooperative also located near Lake Chelan.

IFC affiliate companies acquired both in 2022.

The Manson plaintiffs argue that steps taken by Chelan Fruit and IFC devalued the stock issued to Manson members.

The plaintiffs say the Washington State Investment Board’s financial backing of IFC has influenced how it operates its holdings. The Manson plaintiffs allege that its members suffered as IFC steered its more successful holdings into IFC funds that benefited the state.

IFC opted to keep several senior executives at Manson on the payroll. It is believed that those holdover executives are leading the legal fight. One of them is Jared England, son of the founder of Manson and its senior executive when the deal with IFC was announced.

England declined to comment for this story.

Gail Peterson is a long-time Manson member. She’s still growing apples at age 79 and relies on the cooperative to sell them and for other assistance.

“They’ve always been very good to me,” she said. “Just recently, they sent out a guy to fix my forklift.”

Peterson’s priority is to preserve the small, family farms that have long been the mainstay of the Chelan Valley. She is outraged by the news that IFC is considering building homes on orchard land.

“IFC told us that they shared my desire to preserve farming in this valley,” Peterson said. “They are doing the opposite. They are the developers we were trying to protect ourselves from.”

IFC is just days away from closing its largest deal to date – a $231 million purchase of its once-bitter enemy: Gebbers Farms.

Brewster Heights Orchards & Packing, part of the Gebbers organization, filed bankruptcy in June.

An auction was authorized by a federal bankruptcy judge in Spokane to sell most of the Gebbers assets. An IFC affiliated company bid $231 million. It was the only response the court received.

At a hearing last Thursday, U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Frederick Corbit lauded IFC for stepping into the breach and potentially saving nearly 4,000 jobs.

“I’m pleased that the case has gotten to this point,” the judge said. “It’s important to preserve these jobs. It’s good for Eastern Washington and for the country.”

In a written statement, IFC pledged to spend another $40 million to $50 million over five years modernizing the Gebbers orchards with new irrigation and modern trellis planting methods.

Other growers are terrified at the news. Patrick Colbert, a grower in Tonasket, was a member of the Chelan Fruit board of directors in 2021, which gave him a front-row seat to IFC’s takeover.

He said he rapidly became disillusioned with IFC’s tactics and quit the board when it became clear that IFC would win.

Now, with the Gebbers deal, Colbert will have no choice but to do business again with IFC.

“They’ll have control of every warehouse and packing shed from Chelan north,” Colbert said. “I’m nervous how they’ll treat growers of all sizes.”

IFC insists that it’s a force for good.

“We are farmers and long-term investors in agriculture,” the company said in a written statement. “We are proud to serve our stakeholders including employees, growers, food buyers, investors, and future generations. During an incredibly challenging time for the tree fruit industry, we remain committed to Washington, to the growers and employees we work alongside.”

The Gebbers family said it strongly supports IFC.

“We have seen firsthand International Farming’s respect for what our family has built, for our employees and growers, and for the communities that have supported us for generations,” said Johnny Gebbers, president of the board of Brewster Heights Packing & Orchards. “We share a deep commitment to agriculture and to this region. We look forward to working alongside the IFC team as we build on that legacy and position the business for a strong future.”

SUBMIT A CORRECTION