‘Calculated solicitation of a 12-year-old girl.’ Arizona man sentenced to prison for enticement
Published at
RIGBY — An Arizona man who was accused of having sexually explicit conversations with a 12-year-old girl he met playing the video game Fortnite has been sentenced to 12 years in prison, following an investigation that spanned two states.
Arhen Neil Heineman, 30, was charged in December 2025 with one felony count of inciting a child over the internet.
Background
The investigation was spearheaded by members of the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office, the Pinal County Sheriff’s Office in Arizona and the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, who aided in his arrest.
RELATED | Arizona man arrested in investigation of alleged child enticement over the internet
According to court documents, the victim, a 12-year-old Idaho girl, was playing Fortnite with a family member when they first encountered Heineman through another online friend. When Heineman asked for the girl’s personal cell phone number, the victim gave the family member’s number instead.
The family member told detectives that the messages were “sick, gross things that he was going to do to (the victim).”
Deputies with the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office took photos of the series of messages between Heineman and the family member posing as the victim. Court documents detail the content of the messages, which involve explicit conversations and Heineman stating he did not care that the victim was only 12 years old.
A warrant was obtained, and Heineman was arrested in Arizona City, Arizona.
Heineman appeared in court in July, after signing a plea agreement on June 23, in which the state would argue for no more than five years fixed. This agreement was non-binding on the court, meaning District Judge Daniel Clark could impose a longer sentence.
On Nov. 2, Clark sentenced Heineman to four years fixed and eight years indeterminate, and required him to register as a sex offender.
Over exaggerations and confusing sentencing documents
Attorney Roger J. Hoopes represented Heineman. He argued there were glaring issues within the psychosexual evaluation used to help determine sentencing.
Hoopes said that while his client was charged with two crimes in Arizona, both had been dismissed, and the evaluation should have noted that the current charge would be Heineman’s first felony offense.
He said that while Heineman was on probation for a lesser charge, he had never had a violation, which wasn’t reflected in the evaluation.
“It seems to me, in the psychosexual evaluation, that undue emphasis was placed on this horrendous criminal record,” Hoopes said.
Hoopes also argued the evaluation included contradictory statements regarding Heineman’s alcoholism.
Hoopes recommended that Heineman be sentenced to a retained jurisdiction to allow his client to access treatment and schooling programs available within the rider program.
High risk, deception and other aggravating factors
Jefferson County Chief Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Scott Peterson acknowledged that since his arrest, Heineman cooperated with law enforcement and pre-sentence investigators, and agreed to plead guilty.
But Peterson said that Heineman had reached out to a 12-year-old girl that he met on Fortnite and began to ask for nude images of her. He added that Heineman was listed as having a high likelihood to reoffend.
Peterson said that in the evaluation, Heineman said he was sexually interested in women between the ages of 21 and 35. The evaluator noted that this contradicted the events of the crime “which involved the calculated solicitation of a 12-year-old child,” Peterson read from the evaluation. “This discrepancy further evidences ongoing effort to sanitize his clinical profile and deny his deviant behavior.”
Peterson recommended that the court sentence Heineman to 15 years, with 5 years fixed and 10 years indeterminate.
‘Everybody makes mistakes’
Before Heineman was sentenced, he made a statement to the court.
“Everybody makes mistakes, your honor, and some people make worse mistakes than others,” Heineman said. “However, anybody can change if they genuinely want to.”
Since his arrest, Heineman said that he had sent an apology to the victim and vowed to God that he would never drink alcohol again.
“I want to apologize to the victim, to her family, and to everyone involved, whether directly or indirectly,” Heineman said. “I have dedicated my life in order to not only try to heal the wounds that I have inflicted, but in order to show forth an example of positive change.”
This is a prison case
During sentencing, Clark made it clear that he thought Heineman’s conduct deserved a prison term.
“You knowingly sought out and attempted to elicit provocative pictures and sexual conversations with a 12-year-old. That’s prison conduct, period,” Clark said.
Clark noted that a polygraph administered as part of Heineman’s evaluation indicated he was deceptive about whether he had ever had sex with someone he knew was a minor or thought was a minor. It also indicated he had been deceptive about whether he had engaged in explicit conversations with other minors in the past.
“The question then becomes: With that coupled with the evaluation, does that place you in a position where your risk is either something that can be managed within a retained jurisdiction, or managed on a community-based placement?” Clark asked. “(The) psychosexual evaluator says no, at least based on the risk, and the pre-sentence investigator says no.”
After hearing his 12-year sentence, Heineman told the court he wanted to withdraw his guilty plea. Clark told him to speak with his attorney about it and that he could file the appropriate motions.

