Man who impregnated 15-year-old sent to prison after trying to withdraw guilty plea for a third time - East Idaho News
Submit a name to Secret Santa
Crime Watch

Man who impregnated 15-year-old sent to prison after trying to withdraw guilty plea for a third time

  Published at
Zachary Ausland during his sentencing on Wednesday. | Kaitlyn Hart, EastIdahoNews.com
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready ...

IDAHO FALLS — A 27-year-old man was sentenced to prison on Wednesday after he raped a 15-year-old girl, who ended up giving birth to their baby in 2024.

Zachary Benjamin Thomas Ausland was sentenced by District Judge Brendon Taylor to three years fixed and seven years indeterminate, meaning he could spend up to 10 years in prison.

Ausland was initially charged in Oct. 2024 and pleaded not guilty to felony assault with intent to commit a serious felony of rape.

Between then and now, Ausland accepted two plea agreements, and then withdrew both guilty pleas.

On Wednesday before the sentencing, Ausland’s attorney John Malek argued in favor of a motion to further continue to sentencing, stating that he “misled” his client and that Ausland did not fully understand what punishment the parties were agreeing to in the current plea agreement. It called for four years fixed and three years indeterminate, for a possible maximum of seven years in prison.

“Basically, I don’t know how else to put it, but I misled my client as to what the agreement meant,” said Malek. “I see massive issues with proceedings with sentencing under these circumstances.”

Taylor denied the motion and ruled that the sentencing would continue, stating that Ausland had previously stated on the record that he understood the agreement and had taken ample time to discuss it with Malek.

The case

On Aug. 12, 2024, Bonneville County deputies were dispatched to a home after a report of a disturbance. When they arrived, they learned that a 15-year-old girl had been raped by Ausland, who was 24 at the time, and that she had been impregnated.

Ausland admitted to deputies that he had sex with the victim multiple times, but claimed he “did not know her age until the baby was born.”

Zachary Benjamin Thomas Ausland | Bonneville County Jail
Zachary Benjamin Thomas Ausland | Bonneville County Jail

A forensic interview was scheduled for the victim at the Domestic Violence and Sexual Assault Center, where the victim said she had met Ausland three years before when they both worked at the same restaurant.

The victim stated that the two had sex multiple times, including before and after the baby was born. When asked whether Ausland knew how old she was, the victim said it eventually came up when a friend mentioned her “being so young.”

Ausland reportedly stopped talking to her “for a while” but eventually the two reconnected and continued seeing each other.

On Sept. 7, 2024, deputies reportedly caught Ausland violating a no-contact order by being at the victim’s house. After conducting a search, deputies reportedly also found a used condom with the victim’s DNA on it in his pocket.

Sentencing

No victim impact statements were read at the sentencing because she and others submitted letters for the judge to read and did not wish to read them aloud.

Pat Tucker, a prosecuting attorney, argued that Ausland has caused great harm to the victim and her family, and should be given a prison sentence.

“The victim’s life is changed forever,” said Tucker. “(The) victim is in a position of being intimidated by an older gentleman, being in a position of vulnerability being a minor, being taken in by wiles and guile.”

Tucker stated that she has been shocked by the progression of the case, as she was told by the victim’s family that Ausland seems to have no interest in the child he now has with the victim.

“The defendant did not make overtures, regular visits to see the child in question,” said Tucker. “In this case, we may have a situation where we have a child who is not being given the benefit of responsible fatherhood.”

Tucker recommended that Ausland serve a prison sentence of two years fixed and five years indeterminate, saying that he has shown indifference about the situation.

“The psychosexual evaluation was also unsettling from the standpoint of the finding that the defendant had almost a lack of response, a lack of being able to get beyond self-centeredness, and viewed his crime in terms of the effect on other people,” says Tucker.

Tucker also told the court that there have been allegations that Ausland recently kicked the victim out of the home they are living in together, since she turned 18 and the no-contact order was dropped.

Malek argued for supervised probation and treatment for Ausland, saying that his client and the victim are trying to start a life together and hope to one day be a family that can take care of their child.

“This is a case where it might be an unfortunate situation, but many of the alternatives are worse, because it would break up the family,” said Malek.

Zachary Benjamin Thomas Ausland (left) and his defense attorney, John Malek (right). | Kaitlyn Hart, EastIdahoNews.com
Zachary Benjamin Thomas Ausland (left) and his defense attorney, John Malek (right). | Kaitlyn Hart, EastIdahoNews.com

According to Malek, Ausland has cognitive issues and problems with impulsivity that require professional help.

“I think Mr. Ausland is in that situation where, if time were imposed, he would be around people who have significantly worse issues, not just ADHD and some thinking errors, some selfishness and impulsivity,” said Malek. “I’ve seen improvement in Mr. Ausland. I’ve seen him working, making efforts, making time to cool down, think about the situation and engage with the mother of his child in a productive manner.”

In closing, Malek said he is aware that the public wants to see harsher crimes for sex offenses, but claims that the public doesn’t know the full story.

“People saying those things generally aren’t familiar with the facts of the case,” said Malek. “They don’t see that the victim is here and wanted to live a life with this man.”

Ausland then provided a short statement, apologizing to the court and saying that he has seen the consequences of his actions.

“I’m completely understanding of the wrongs I’ve done. I do definitely deserve a punishment for what I did. I’ve done a lot of thinking about how it can affect her as being a teenage mom, and how much stress it puts on her,” said Ausland. “And I’d just appreciate, if at all possible, if I could stay and be a part of my family and provide for my son, and for her. I’m making moves to be a better person. I continuously am trying to stay busy or work, to get home and show her love and affection, and see my kid whenever I can.”

Before pronouncing sentence, Taylor spoke to the court about the seriousness of the crime.

“When he was 24 years old, he had relations with a 15-year-old that resulted in a pregnancy,” said Taylor. “There’s an imbalance of power, there’s an imbalance of life experience, and it’s illegal conduct.”

SUBMIT A CORRECTION